Sample results from I1* “x cluster”
Formerly known as “Ix” but now renamed to distinguish it from the other I1* cluster, which we will in turn call the “y cluster”!
Last updated: 2/01/2006 2:58 PM
Here is a table where I am gathering the known examples from www.ysearch.org and http://smgf.org.
I am doing this based upon information made available by Ken Nordtvedt at http://www.northwestanalysis.net/
For John McEwan’s results see http://www.geocities.com/mcewanjc/p3modal.htm and especially http://www.geocities.com/mcewanjc/37strallhapigv2.pdf
This cluster is in haplogroup I1 but not I1a, I1b, or I1c, so for the time being I shall call it the I1* “x cluster”. (It used to be referred to as the “Ix” haplogroup, until SNP tests were done on Glen Todd.)
I have sorted into rough clusters of similar haplotypes. DYS448 appears particularly informative, as this is largely bi-modal (19 or 21, with a small group of 20s). DYS385 and DYS459 are also helpful. This is all tentative.
Colouring:
Results above the modal for this cluster are pink (1 repeat more than modal), magenta (2 repeats), red (3 repeats), or purple (>3 repeats higher than the mode).
Results below the modal for this cluster are yellow (pale yellow for 1 step, brighter yellow for 2 steps) or green (more than 2 steps less than the mode).
Please contact me with questions or comments at Andrew “dot” Lancaster “at” Skynet “dot” be.
User ID	Last Name	Origin	3	3	1	3	3	3	4	3	4	3	3	3	3	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	4	H	Y	Y	4	6	5	5	C	C	4	4	4	4	A	C	1	4	4	4	4	4	4
			9	9	9	9	8	8	2	8	3	8	9	8	8	5	5	5	5	5	4	3	4	4	6	6	6	6	6	4	C	C	5	0	7	7	D	D	4	3	6	6	1	4	B	4	4	4	4	5	6
			3	0		1	5	5	6	8	9	9	2	9	9	8	9	9	5	4	7	7	8	9	4	4	4	4	0		A	A	6	7	6	0	Y	Y	2	8	1	2	0		0	1	4	5	6	2	3
							a	b				|		|	B		a	b							a	b	c	d			I	I					a	b							7
												1		2																	I	I
																															a	b
	max		14	27	17	11	15	20	11	15	13	13	12	30	18	20	11	11	12	12	27	16	21	32	14	15	15	16	11	10	19	21	15	15	19	19	36	38	14	11	14	13	14	24	11	15	14	12	13	11	22
	modal		13	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	28	14	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	14	14	16	18	35	36	12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
	average		13	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	8	10	10	12	25	15	20	28	14	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	14	14	16	18	34	36	12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
	min		12	23	14	9	11	14	11	13	8	11	11	27	15	15	8	9	9	6	22	14	18	26	13	14	14	14	9	8	19	19	13	13	15	16	31	34	11	8	10	11	11	20	9	13	11	11	9	10	19
	max-min		2	4	3	2	4	6	0	2	5	2	1	3	3	5	3	2	3	6	5	2	3	6	1	1	1	2	2	2	0	2	2	2	4	3	5	4	3	3	4	2	3	4	2	2	3	1	4	1	3
BAYSF	Boucher	Unknown	13	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	18	28	14	14	15	15	10	10	19	19	14	14	19	17	35	37	12	8
FDYGZ	Boucher	Unknown	13	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	18	28	14	14	15	15	10	10	19	19	14	14	18	17	35	38	12	8
SMGF	Dale	USA	13	24	17	10	14	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	27					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	12	21	11	15	13	11	12	10	20
SMGF	Lems	Netherlands	13	25	15	11	13	16	11	15	11	12	11	29	17	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	27					11	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	11	22	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Helms	USA	13	25	16	11	13	14	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	11	25	15	19	27					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Garscadden	Scotland	13	24	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	15	8	10	10	12	26	15	19	27					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	22	11	14	13	11	10	10	20
SMGF	Smith	USA	13	24	16	11	13	17	11	13	11	13	11	28	15	15	8	10	10	12	26	15	19	27					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	13	12	23	11	14	13	11	10	10	20
SMGF	Hansen etc	Denmark	13	24	17	10	13	15	11	13	11	12	11	29	17	15	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28					10	9	19	19	14						12	11	13	12	12	22	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Brooks	USA	14	24	15	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	29	17	17	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28					10	10	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	24	11	13	13	11	12	11	20
N45D5	Davis	Unknown	13	24	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28	14	15	15	15	10	9	19	19	14	15	16	18	36	36	13	10
SMGF	Van Hoesen	USA	13	25	15	10	14	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	18	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28					11	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	12	21	11	13	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Tietjen etc	Germany	13	25	17	10	14	16	11	13	11	12	11	29	17	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28					10	10	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	22	11	14	12	11	10	11	20
R3EY7	Chewning	England	13	25	17	11	13	17	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28	14	14	14	15	10	9	19	19	14	14	16	18	35	36	11	10
6WNX5	Steinmetz	USA	13	26	15	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	24	14	19	28	14	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	15	15	15	17	34	38	12	10
SMGF	Milner	England	14	26	16	11	15	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	18	8	10	10	11	24	15	19	28					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Beidler	USA	13	26	17	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	14	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Ellis	England	13	26	17	11	14	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	11	12	24	15	19	28					11	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	20	10	14	13	11	11	10	20
D3PAQ	Waterous	USA	13	26	17	11	15	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	19	8	10	10	12	25	15	19	28	14	14	15	15	10	9	19	20	13	14	16	18	34	34	11	10
SMGF	Fosson	Italy	13	24	16	10	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	23	15	19	28					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	10	12	12	22	11	14	12	11	11	10	20
8GEWA	Gray	England	13	24	16	11	15	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	18	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28	13	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	14	14	16	18	31	34	11	10
APRBY	Daniel	Unknown	13	24	16	11	15	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	20	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28	13	14	15	15
9GDC6	Doane	Unknown	12	25	15	11	15	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	8	10	10	11	24	15	19	29	13	14	14	15	10	9	19	19	14	15	16	18	34	34	11	10
SMGF	Doan	USA	12	25	16	11	15	17	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	8	10	10	11	24	15	19	29					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	12	12	11	10	20
SMGF	Quada	USA	13	27	16	10	13	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	17	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28					10	9	19	19	13						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	12	11	12	10	20
SMGF	Sherolt Tribino	Brazil	13	26	17	10	13	16	11	13	12	12	11	29	17	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	28					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	12	12	13	21	11	15	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Leyva Alvitres	Peru	14	26	16	11	14	16	11	13	10	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	29					10	10	19	19	14						12	10	12	12	12	21	11	14	14	11	12	10	19
SMGF	Walker	England	14	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	18	8	9	10	12	25	15	19	29					10	8	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Jackson	England	13	26	17	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	-	19	29					10	9	19	19	15						-	10	13	-	-	-	-	14	-	11	-	-	20
JHH9G	Rogers	USA	13	25	16	11	14	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	18	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	29	13	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	14	14	16	18	32	34	11	10
SMGF	Rodgers	Canada	13	25	16	11	14	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	18	8	10	10	12	24	15	19	29					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
VUERB	Hartung	Germany	13	27	16	10	13	17	11	13	11	13	12	29	16	16	8	10	10	12	23	15	19	30	14	14	15	15	11	9	19	19	14	14	17	16	35	37	12	11
SMGF	Maxon	USA	13	26	17	10	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	6	24	14	19	30					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	14	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Daniels	USA	13	24	16	11	14	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	15	8	10	10	12	25	15	19	30					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	13	21	-	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Daly	Ireland	13	25	16	11	12	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	19	8	10	10	12	25	15	19	30					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	13	21	-	14	13	11	11	10	20
X66FF	Connolly	Ireland	13	24	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	15	8	10	10	12	25	15	19	31	14	14	15	15	10	9	19	21	15	15	17	19	32	36	12	10
8GD73	Brion	France	13	25	16	11	13	15	11	15	11	12	11	28	16	15	8	10	10	11	25	15	19	31	14	14	15	15	9	9	19	19	13	14	16	18	34	35	12	11
SMGF	Brion		13	25	16	11	13	15	11	15	11	12	11	29	17	15	8	10	10	11	25	15	19	31					9	9	19	19	13						12	11	13	11	12	22	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	King/Le Roi	Canada	12	25	17	11	13	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	16	10	10	10	12	24	15	19	27					10	10	19	19	13						11	10	12	12	13	22	11	15	13	11	11	11	20
SMGF	Lay	USA	12	26	17	11	13	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	16	-	-	10	-	24	15	19	26					10	10	19	19	-						11	10	12	12	13	22	11	15	13	-	11	11	20
HMYTE	Lay	USA	12	25	17	11	14	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	16	10	10	10	11	24	15	19	27	14	14	14	14	10	10	19	19	13	15	16	19	35	35	11	10
SMGF	Knight	England	13	25	15	11	14	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	10	10	10	12	22	16	19	28					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	14	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Mills	USA	13	26	16	10	14	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	18	10	10	10	12	24	15	19	28					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
PJ7UT	MacLeay	Scotland	13	25	15	10	11	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	20	29	14	14	15	15
6D9UQ	McKinney	Unknown	13	25	15	10	11	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	20	29	14	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	14	14	17	18	34	34	12	10
KV9NE	Rose	Unknown	13	25	15	10	11	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	20	28	14	14	15	15
2AADH	McKinzey	Scotland	13	24	15	11	11	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16
SMGF	Hamon	Channel Is	13	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	8	9	10	12	25	15	20	28					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	11	23	11	13	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Hamblin	England	13	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	8	9	10	12	25	15	20	29					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	12	24	11	13	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Gunther	Germany	13	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	8	9	12	11	26	15	21	28					10	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	12	13	21	11	13	12	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Morris	USA	13	25	16	11	13	16	11	13	12	12	11	27	15	17	8	9	10	12	24	15	21	29					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	12	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Claybaugh	USA	13	25	15	10	13	17	11	13	12	12	11	27	15	17	8	9	10	12	25	15	21	28					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	20	11	15	13	11	13	10	20
SMGF	Cornwell	USA	13	25	15	11	13	17	11	13	12	12	11	27	15	17	8	9	10	12	25	15	21	28					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	20	11	14	13	11	12	10	20
SMGF	Parish	Canada	13	23	16	11	13	17	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	15	8	9	10	12	25	15	21	26					9	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	13	12	21	11	14	13	11	9	11	21
SMGF	Teale	England	13	24	16	11	13	17	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	15	8	9	10	12	25	15	21	26					9	9	19	19	14						11	10	13	13	12	22	11	14	14	11	9	11	21
SMGF	Pedersen etc	Denmark	12	25	16	10	13	17	11	13	8	12	11	28	16	16	8	9	10	12	25	15	21	28					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	12	12	12	21	11	14	14	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Mahan	USA	12	25	17	11	13	16	11	13	12	13	11	29	16	16	8	9	10	12	24	15	21	27					10	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
BTE2U	Levack	Scotland	13	24	17	11	13	15	11	13	11	12	11	29	17	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26	14	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	15	14	16	19	34	37	12	10
ADJA3	Hudson	Unknown	13	24	17	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26	14	14	15	15
WQUH5	Stanley	Unknown	13	24	17	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26	14	14	15	15
F5M64	Harris-adopted	Scotland	13	24	17	11	13	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26	13	14	15	15
SMGF	Standage	England	13	24	17	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26					11	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	22	9	15	12	11	9	11	21
DZ53W	Brinley	Unknown	13	24	17	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26	14	14	15	16	10	9	19	19	14	14	16	19	35	36	12	10
SMGF	Worthington	NZ	13	24	17	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	17	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26					11	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	14	11	9	-	-
FZF85	Grimes	USA	13	24	17	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16
PCBS3	Hawkins	Unknown	13	24	17	11	13	16	11	13	10	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	27	13	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	13	14	16	19	34	37	12	10
CUXMQ	FLORY	Unknown	13	25	16	10	13	19	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	23	15	21	29	14	15	15	15
GFCJX	Flory	Unknown	13	25	16	10	13	19	11	13	11	11	11	28	17	16	8	10	10	12	23	15	21	29	14	15	15	15
Z9X3R	Gilmore	Unknown	13	25	16	10	13	20	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	23	15	21	30	14	15	15	15	11	10	19	19	15	14	16	17	35	35	12	10
8VWK5	Creswick	Germany	13	25	14	11	13	16	11	14	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	27	14	14	15	15	10	9	19	19	14	13	16	17	36	37	12	10
X22KV	Greene	Germany	13	25	14	11	13	17	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	18	8	10	10	12	24	15	21	27	14	14	15	15
SMGF	Findley	USA	13	25	15	11	13	16	11	13	10	12	11	28	16	17	8	10	10	12	24	15	21	28					10	10	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Tavernier	France	13	24	15	11	13	16	11	13	11	12	11	28	16	15	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	28					10	9	19	19	14						14	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Gandola	Italy	13	25	15	11	15	16	11	14	11	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26					10	9	19	19	14						13	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	12	11	11	10	20
SMGF	Ashby	USA	13	24	15	11	13	16	11	13	12	12	11	28	16	16	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	26					11	9	19	19	14						12	10	13	12	12	21	11	14	13	11	9	-	21
	Bailey	Germany	13	25	15	11	15	16	11	14	13	12	11	29	17	17	8	10	10	12	25	15	21	27					10	9	19	19	14						13	10	12	12	13	20	11	14	13	11	11	11	21
	Bailey	USA	13	25	15